These Are the 10 Best Thrift Stores in New Jersey for Any Kind of Shopper

Eva Hagan - Author

Dec. 26 2023, Published 11:53 a.m. ET

Photo of a local thrift store with two flowers painted on the wall.
Source: iStock

When shopping for clothes nowadays, it’s becoming harder and harder to avoid fast fashion brands. Even brands that claim to be sustainable might not be what you think. However, one thing is for sure: buying clothing secondhand, no matter what brand it is, is better than buying clothing new, because it prevents another thing from heading to the landfill.

Article continues below advertisement

Luckily for you, thrift stores are becoming more popular and chances are you can find one to shop at no matter where you are. So, here are 10 of the best thrift stores in New Jersey.

A close-up photo of a clothing rack of pants in a thrift store.
Source: iStock


At 227 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, N.J., Thriftnicks is a secondhand hotspot for miscellaneous goods, such as antiques, sports equipment, toys, and vintage fashion.

Article continues below advertisement

The Center Square

Located at 800 Main Street, Belmar, N.J., The Center Square prides itself as being “not your ordinary thrift shop.” That’s because in this store you can find all your usual thrift expectations of clothing, household decor, and random knick-knacks, but it’s run by a nonprofit that works to provide services for those living with HIV/AIDS.

Article continues below advertisement

Junior League of Summit

At 37 DeForest Avenue, Summit, N.J., Junior League of Summit is another shop with an important mission. All the funds from the bargain store, which sells clothing, toys, decorations, furniture, and more, are used to fund grants, scholarships, and projects to give back to women in the community.

Article continues below advertisement

Woodstock Vibes

At 3235 Route 94, Franklin, N.J., Woodstock Vibes is a high-end thrift shop known for hand-picked clothing items.

Article continues below advertisement

Thrift Shop of Hope

Located at 79 W Palisade Ave, Englewood, N.J., Thrift Shop of Hope is a secondhand shop with a variety of cool finds. If you are looking to see what it has lately, new arrivals are posted on Facebook.

Article continues below advertisement

Family Thrift Store of Howell, New Jersey

At 2929 US-9, Howell Township, N.J., the Family Thrift Store offers endless browsing of men’s, women’s, and children’s clothing, as well as shoes, and accessories. You can find Family Thrifts in three locations in New Jersey.

Article continues below advertisement

Passaic Thrift

Located at 212 Madison St, Passaic, N.J., Passaic Thrift prides itself as a place to find high-end quality clothing. Another plus is that Passaic Thrift is known to be a clean and organized store.

Article continues below advertisement

Little Treasure Thrift Shop

At 2 Maple Ave, Montclair, N.J., Little Treasure Thrift Shop could be the place to find new vintage items. With secondhand treasures of every variety, you could be browsing forever in this store.

Article continues below advertisement

Independent Thrift shop

Located at 39 Kings Road, Madison, N.J., Independent Thrift Shop is a secondhand store where all the proceeds go to local charities. The store often has a paper bag sale, where you can buy anything that fits in a paper bag for a fixed price.

Article continues below advertisement

Westfield Service League Thrift Shop

At 114 Elmer Street, Westfield, N.J., Westfield Service League Thrift Shop has been supplying the community with secondhand goods for around 90 years. And the best part is, all the money from purchases goes to local nonprofits.

More from Green Matters

Latest Sustainable Fashion News and Updates

    Opt-out of personalized ads

    © Copyright 2024 Green Matters. Green Matters is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.